Mystery Lot: Guess the Auction Item

Every Friday, Cardinal Auction Services posts a close-up of a real lot from an upcoming Virginia auction. Guess what it is, follow the weekend hints, and get the answer on Monday.

This week’s Mystery Lot: October 2 to 5, 2026

Close-up of a brass stud on a worn brown leather strap, this week's Mystery Lot

This bit of brass and leather belongs to a real lot in our October 8 online consignment auction in Amelia, Virginia. What is it from?

  • A. A country doctor’s saddlebag
  • B. A railroad conductor’s ticket pouch
  • C. A soldier’s cartridge box
  • D. A surveyor’s instrument case

Hint #1: the back

Back of a worn brown leather case with two belt loops, Mystery Lot Hint #1

Those two loops slid onto a belt, and whoever wore it didn’t buy it. It was issued to them. Does that change your guess?

Hint #2 comes Sunday. The answer goes up Monday.

How the game works

  • Friday: we post one close-up photo and four possible answers.
  • Saturday and Sunday: one hint each day. You can change your guess.
  • Monday: we post the answer, the full story of the item, and the lot number so you can bid on it.

Every Mystery Lot is a real item you can bid on. Nothing is staged and nothing comes from a stock photo.

The auction it comes from

This week’s item is one of 245 lots in our October 8 Online Consignment Auction in Amelia, Virginia. The sale is strong in antique American stoneware and pottery, antique furniture, and clocks. Bidding closes Thursday, October 8 at 10:00 AM, with preview on October 6 by appointment.

Have something interesting to sell?

Cardinal Auction Services runs online estate and consignment auctions for families, collectors, and businesses across Greater Richmond and central Virginia. If you have antiques, collectibles, military items, tools, or a whole house to settle, tell us what you have.

See how consigning works, send us a message, or call 804-677-6281.

Past Mystery Lots

This is the first one. Each Monday’s answer will be added here.

Scroll to Top

Get a Free Consultation Now!

Subscribe To Our Newsletter